EFFECT OF OUTSOLE THICKNESS ON RUNNING BIOMECHANICS
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
Running shoes with increased or decreased sole thickness are postulated to improve running performance, besides to protect runners against high impact forces and running injuries. However, there is no evidence showing that running shoe developments emerging on the market help tackle running injuries. In this study, we compared the effect of different outsole thicknesses: (i) barefoot, (ii) minimalist and (iii) maximalist sports shoes on running biomechanics. Fifteen male subjects (age 23.19 ± 0.73 years old) who had regular exercises for at least 75 minutes per week were recruited to participate in this study. Participants had completed three minutes of running on a treadmill in each condition. Lower extremity kinetics and kinematics were analysed. There was no difference between maximalist running shoes and minimalist running shoes with respect to maximum vertical ground reaction force (VGRF) (p = 0.221), step length (p = 0.50) and cadence (p = 0.30). In addition, we observed longer ground contact time in maximalist running shoes (1.087 ± 0.115 s) when compared with minimalist running shoes (1.051 ± 0.105 s) (p = 0.007). On the other hand, runners had significantly higher knee flexion and adduction in minimalist shoes than maximalist shoes (p = 0.046). In conclusion, running in minimalist shoes, at least in a short period, produces greater running efficiency with shorter ground contact time but may result in a higher injury risk at the knee joint.
Downloads
Article Details
Licensee MJS, Universiti Malaya, Malaysia. This article is an open-access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
References
Agresta, C., Kessler, S., Southern, E., Goulet, G. C., Zernicke, R. & Zendler, J. D. (2018). Immediate and short-term adaptations to maximalist and minimalist running shoes, Footwear Science 10(2): 95-107.
Aksenov, A. & Klishkovskaya, T. (2017). Video-analysis of the effect of different types of adapted shoes on knee adduction moment, Pediatric Traumatology, Orthopaedics and Reconstructive Surgery 5(1): 45-52.
Aminaka, N., Arthur, K., Porcari, J. P., Foster, C., Cress, M. & Hahn, C. (2018). No immediate effects of highly cushioned shoes on basic running biomechanics, Kinesiology 50(1): 124-130.
Bertelsen, M. L., Jensen, J. F., Nielsen, M. H., Nielsen, R. O. & Rasmussen, S. (2013). Footstrike patterns among novice runners wearing a conventional, neutral running shoe, Gait & posture 38(2): 354-356.
Birmingham, T. B., Hunt, M. A., Jones, I. C., Jenkyn, T. R. & Giffin, J. R. (2007). Test–retest reliability of the peak knee adduction moment during walking in patients with medial compartment knee osteoarthritis, Arthritis Care & Research 57(6): 1012-1017.
Bonacci, J., Saunders, P. U., Hicks, A., Rantalainen, T., Vicenzino, B. G. T. & Spratford, W. (2013) Running in a minimalist and lightweight shoe is not the same as running barefoot: a biomechanical study, British journal of sports medicine 47(6): 387-392.
Bonacci, J., Vicenzino, B., Spratford, W. & Collins, P. (2014). Take your shoes off to reduce patellofemoral joint stress during running, British journal of sports medicine 48(6): 425-428.
Borgia, B. & Becker, J. (2019). Lower extremity stiffness when running in minimalist, traditional, and ultra-cushioning shoes, Footwear Science 11(1): 45-54.
Chambon, N., Delattre, N., Guéguen, N., Berton, E. and Rao, G. (2014). Is midsole thickness a key parameter for the running pattern?. Gait & posture, 40(1): 58-63.
Cheung, R. T., & Ngai, S. P. (2016). Effects of footwear on running economy in distance runners: A meta-analytical review, Journal of science and medicine in sport 19(3): 260-266.
Chowdhury, S. and Kumar, N. (2013). Estimation of forces and moments of lower limb joints from kinematics data and inertial properties of the body by using inverse dynamics technique, Journal of Rehabilitation Robotics 1(2): 93-98.
De Wit, B., De Clercq, D. & Aerts, P. (2000). Biomechanical analysis of the stance phase during barefoot and shod running, Journal of biomechanics 33(3): 269-278.
DeMers, M. S., Pal, S. & Delp, S. L. (2014). Changes in tibiofemoral forces due to variations in muscle activity during walking, Journal of orthopaedic research 32(6): 769-776.
Esculier, J. F., Dubois, B., Dionne, C. E., Leblond, J. & Roy, J. S. (2015). A consensus definition and rating scale for minimalist shoes, Journal of foot and ankle research 8(1): 42.
Ferber, R. & Macdonald, S. (2014). Running mechanics and gait analysis, Human Kinetics.
Fredericks, W., Swank, S., Teisberg, M., Hampton, B., Ridpath, L. & Hanna, J. B. (2015). Lower extremity biomechanical relationships with different speeds in traditional, minimalist, and barefoot footwear, Journal of Sports Science & Medicine 14(2): 276.
Gazendam, M. G. & Hof, A. L. (2007). Averaged EMG profiles in jogging and running at different speeds, Gait & posture 25(4): 604-614.
Gillinov, S. M., Laux, S., Kuivila, T., Hass, D. & Joy, S. M. (2015). Effect of minimalist footwear on running efficiency: A randomized crossover trial, Sports health 7(3): 256-260.
Hall, J. P., Barton, C., Jones, P. R. & Morrissey, D. (2013). The biomechanical differences between barefoot and shod distance running: a systematic review and preliminary meta-analysis, Sports Medicine 43(12): 1335-1353.
Hein, T. & Grau, S. (2014). Can minimal running shoes imitate barefoot heel-toe running patterns? A comparison of lower leg kinematics, Journal of Sport and Health Science 3(2): 67-73.
Hobara, H., Sato, T., Sakaguchi, M. & Nakazawa, K. (2012). Step frequency and lower extremity loading during running, International journal of sports medicine 33(04): 310-313.
Hollander, K., Argubi-Wollesen, A., Reer, R. & Zech, A. (2015). Comparison of minimalist footwear strategies for simulating barefoot running: a randomized crossover study, PloS one 10(5): e0125880.
Hsu, A. R. (2012). Topical review: barefoot running, Foot & Ankle International 33(9): 787-794.
Hulme A., Nielsen. R O., Timpka T., Verhagen E. & Finch C. (2017). Risk and protective factors for middle- and long-distance running-related injury, Sport Med. 47: 869–886.
Kulmala, J. P., Kosonen, J., Nurminen, J. & Avela, J. (2018). Running in highly cushioned shoes increases leg stiffness and amplifies impact loading, Scientific reports 8(1): 1-7.
Law, M.H., Choi, E.M., Law, S.H., Chan, S.S., Wong, S.M., Ching, E.C., Chan, Z.Y., Zhang, J.H., Lam, G.W., Lau, F.O. and Cheung, R.T. (2019). Effects of footwear midsole thickness on running biomechanics. Journal of sports sciences, 37(9): 1004-1010.
Lee D C., Brellenthin A G., Thompson P D., Sui X., Lee I. M. & Lavie C. J. (2017). Running as a key lifestyle medicine for longevity, Progress in cardiovascular diseases 60(1): 45-55.
Lieberman, D. E., Venkadesan, M., Werbel, W. A., Daoud, A. I., D’andrea, S., Davis, I. S., ... & Pitsiladis, Y. (2010). Foot strike patterns and collision forces in habitually barefoot versus shod runners, Nature 463(7280): 531-535.
Lohman III, E. B., Sackiriyas, K. S. B., & Swen, R. W. (2011). A comparison of the spatiotemporal parameters, kinematics, and biomechanics between shod, unshod, and minimally supported running as compared to walking, Physical Therapy in Sport 12(4): 151-163.
Mei Q., Gu Y., Sun D. & Fernandez J. (2018). How foot morphology changes influence shoe comfort and plantar pressure before and after long distance running? Acta Bioeng. Biomech 20: 179–186.
Moore, I. S., Jones, A. & Dixon, S. (2014) The pursuit of improved running performance: Can changes in cushioning and somatosensory feedback influence running economy and injury risk? Footwear Science 6(1): 1-11.
Nagano, H., Tatsumi, I., Sarashina, E., Sparrow, W.A. and Begg, R.K. (2015). Modelling knee flexion effects on joint power absorption and adduction moment, The Knee 22(6): 490-493.
Nin, D. Z., Lam, W. K. & Kong, P. W. (2016). Effect of body mass and midsole hardness on kinetic and perceptual variables during basketball landing manoeuvre, Journal of sports sciences 34(8): 756-765.
Pohl, M. B., Hamill, J. & Davis, I. S. (2009). Biomechanical and anatomic factors associated with a history of plantar fasciitis in female runners, Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine 19(5): 372-376.
Pollard, C. D., Ter Har, J. A., Hannigan, J. J. & Norcross, M. F. (2018). Influence of maximal running shoes on biomechanics before and after a 5K run, Orthopaedic journal of sports medicine 6(6): 2325967118775720.
Radzimski, A. O., Mündermann, A. & Sole, G. (2012). Effect of footwear on the external knee adduction moment—a systematic review, The knee 19(3): 163-175.
Ridge, S. T., Johnson, A. W., Mitchell, U. H., Hunter, I., Robinson, E., Rich, B. S. & Brown, S. D. (2013). Foot bone marrow edema after a 10-wk transition to minimalist running shoes.
Ryan, M., Elashi, M., Newsham-West, R. & Taunton, J. (2014). Examining injury risk and pain perception in runners using minimalist footwear, British Journal of Sports Medicine 48(16): 1257-1262.
Sinclair, J., Atkins, S. & Taylor, P. J. (2016a). The effects of barefoot and shod running on limb and joint stiffness characteristics in recreational runners, Journal of Motor Behavior 48(1): 79-85.
Sinclair, J., Fau-Goodwin, J., Richards, J. & Shore, H. (2016b). The influence of minimalist and maximalist footwear on the kinetics and kinematics of running, Footwear Science 8(1): 33-39.
Sinclair, J., Richards, J. & Shore, H. (2015). Effects of minimalist and maximalist footwear on Achilles tendon load in recreational runners, Comparative Exercise Physiology 11(4): 239-244.
Sinclair, J., Shore, H. & Dillon, S. (2016c). The effect of minimalist, maximalist and energy return footwear of equal mass on running economy and substrate utilization, Comparative Exercise Physiology 12(1): 49-54.
Squadrone, R. & Gallozzi, C. (2009). Biomechanical and physiological comparison of barefoot and two shod conditions in experienced barefoot runners, Journal of sports medicine and physical fitness 49(1): 6.
Squadrone, R., Rodano, R., Hamill, J. & Preatoni, E. (2015). Acute effect of different minimalist shoes on foot strike pattern and kinematics in rearfoot strikers during running, Journal of sports sciences 33(11): 1196-1204.
Sun, X., Lam, W. K., Zhang, X., Wang, J., & Fu, W. (2020). Systematic review of the role of footwear constructions in running biomechanics: Implications for running-related injury and performance. Journal of sports science & medicine, 19(1): 20.
Tam, N., Wilson, J. L. A., Noakes, T. D. & Tucker, R. (2014). Barefoot running: an evaluation of current hypothesis, future research and clinical applications, British journal of sports medicine 48(5): 349-355.
Warne, J. P., Kilduff, S. M., Gregan, B. C., Nevill, A. M., Moran, K. A. & Warrington, G. D. (2014). A 4‐week instructed minimalist running transition and gait‐retraining changes plantar pressure and force, Scandinavian journal of medicine & science in sports 24(6): 964-973.
Willy, R. W. & Davis, I. S. (2014). Kinematic and kinetic comparison of running in standard and minimalist shoes, Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise 46(2): 318-323.
Zadpoor, Amir Abbas, & Ali Asadi Nikooyan. (2011). The relationship between lower-extremity stress fractures and the ground reaction force: a systematic review, Clinical biomechanics 26(1): 23-28.